ANDY COAKLEY
Coakley's "All Time" Team
Home
Early Life and Major League Career
Columbia's Coach
Coaching Lou Gehrig
Other Top Players
After Columbia
Coakley's "All Time" Team
Helpful Links
Bibliography
While still coaching Columbia in the mid-1940's, Coakley, who, after over four decades in the game, was considered by the Spectator a "shrewd judge of baseball talent" put together a list of the players that would appear on his all-time all-star major league baseball squad. Click on each photo to view the player's career statistics.
lou_gehrigcolumbia.jpg
http://209.35.163.234/special/sports99/photo/
Lou Gehrig, first base. [See separate biographical entry on this site.]
lajoie_nap.jpg
http://www.baseballhalloffame.org/ hofers_and_honorees/wallpaper/lajoie_nap.jpg
Nap Lajoie, second base. "A constant threat to pitchers," Coakley said, "he was also a most graceful infielder. Everything he did was effortless."
wagner1893-16.jpg
http://www.exploratorium.edu/baseball/tm-cards/wagner1893-16.jpg
Honus Wagner, shortstop. "There wasn't a thing he couldn't do," said Coakley.
 
 
baberuth.jpg
http://www.buhs.k12.ca.us/FPwebs/WEB%20RC/images/Babe%20ruth.jpg
George Herman "Babe" Ruth, Outfield
 
 
sockalexis.jpg
http://www.holycross.edu/departments/publicaffairs/ hcm/spring00/fea24.htm
Louis Sockalexis, Outfield. "He wasn't only the greatest centerfielder, he was also the greatest athlete of all time," Coakley said of perhaps his most surprising choice on the team. "He could run as fast as Cobb, had an arm like Bob Meusel, hit like Ruth, and fielded as well as [Tris] Speaker." Sockalexis, an obscure turn-of-the-century player who spent just three seasons in the big leagues, also happened to have been a fellow alumnus of Holy Cross, Coakley's alma mater.
 
 
mathewson.jpg
http://www.leaptoad.com/raindelay/matty/portrait.jpg
Christy Mathewson, Pitcher "Not only was he a great student of the game," Coakley said, "but he could outguess most of the batters who faced him. He had perfect control of a blinding fastball and a unique fallaway pitch which would break straight down." Coakley was especially partial to Mathewson because he had faced the Giants hurler in the 1905 World Series -- and lost, 9-0.
collins_jimmy.jpg
http://www.baseballhalloffame.org/ hofers_and_honorees/wallpaper/collins_jimmy.jpg
Jimmy Collins, Third Base "The perfect third-sacker," Coakley said. "I've never seen anyone come in so fast on bunts as he."
 
 
cobb.gif
https://members.tripod.com/~protherj/bbl/pictures.html
Ty Cobb, Outfield
 
 
bresnahan_roger.jpg
http://www.baseballhalloffame.org/hofers_and_honorees/ wallpaper/bresnahan_roger.jpg
Roger Bresnahan, Catcher "One of the finest baserunners in the game, and one of the few backstops who ever led off a batting order," said Coakley.
 
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Coakley also mentioned several "contemporary" ballplayers of that time who might one day be considered "greats" -- including Joe DiMaggio, Ted Williams, and Bob Feller.